The NBTA welcomes CRT’s decision to postpone the public consultation until March 2027. Taking more time to consider the views of boaters is sensible, but the delay must result in more than a better-presented consultation. It must address the fundamental problems with the licence review itself.
CRT says it has heard calls for greater consistency, better data, clearer communication and a proportionate, welfare-led approach to enforcement using existing legislation. These are all things that the NBTA has consistently pushed for CRT to rectify, as often they stem from shortcomings in CRT’s own administration and enforcement practices. CRT don’t need to hold consultations or seek legislative change to improve these things.
We have repeatedly warned CRT against creating solutions in search of a problem. Poor data, inadequate communication and inconsistent administration cannot automatically be blamed on legislation, nor will changing the law necessarily resolve them. The review should have started with the fundamentals and considered more ambitious changes only where evidence demonstrated they were necessary.
There is also an important issue missing from CRT’s email. During the pre-consultation meetings, boating representatives repeatedly identified the surcharge on boats without home moorings as a major obstacle to rebuilding trust. If CRT really wants to put boaters’ lived experience and welfare at the heart of this process, it must address this policy rather than continue to overlook it.
The NBTA has consistently engaged with this review in good faith and has repeatedly raised concerns about its assumptions, evidence, representation and lack of procedural neutrality. The additional time must now be used to address those concerns, not simply to refine a process whose direction was effectively established before boaters were properly consulted.
In its January update, we expect CRT to demonstrate that it has genuinely reconsidered its approach, that no predetermined outcome is being pursued, and that the forthcoming consultation will allow boaters to question whether the problems identified actually exist, examine their causes and consider a full range of possible solutions.
The waterways are not an abstract administrative problem to be solved on paper. They are living, working places, and the people who live on them deserve better than solutions in search of a problem.
Original text of CRT’s email:
We’re writing to update you on our work following the independent Commission on Boat Licensing and the co-design we’ve been carrying out with boaters ahead of a consultation to make our boat licensing system clearer, fairer, and fit for the future.
We’ve listened to the feedback from the co-design workshops and we’re moving the public consultation to March 2027. The additional time will allow us to fully reflect on what we have heard and build a robust plan that puts your lived experience at the heart of the consultation proposals.
We will be publishing a full update at the end of January 2027. This will include the complete outcomes of our co-design work, the specific items that will be going forward to public consultation, and the improvements we are delivering right away.
What we’ve heard
Over recent months, 90 boating representatives have taken part in online and in-person workshops, including boating organisations, advisory groups and our new Citizens’ Boater Panel of 40 independently selected boaters.
Some clear themes have emerged from the co-design work. You told us that we need to:
Take the time needed to get the next stage right rather than rush into consultation.
Focus on consistency, making better use of our existing powers, improving how they are applied and ensuring our data is accurate.
Communicate clearly, using plain English, explaining the evidence behind proposals and recognising the different ways people live, work and boat on the waterways.
Take a proportionate, welfare-led approach, considering individual circumstances, welfare needs, and differences across the network.
There was also strong support for separating the Commission’s 36 recommendations into practical improvements that can be taken forward now and more complex issues that require wider consultation.
Thank you
Thank you to everyone who has contributed so far. We appreciate the time, different perspectives and passion for the waterways you’ve brought to this work, and we’ll continue to keep you updated as it progresses.
Warm regards,
Canal & River Trust
